Former Democratic Party boss says Brooklyn candidates complaining about petition challenges should play “big guys’ game”

By Sam Bojarski

frank seddio
A political club led by former Democratic Party boss Frank Seddio is leading an effort to challenge the nominating petitions of several council candidates. Photo by Stefano Giovannini, Brooklyn Paper

Several candidates for a southeast Brooklyn City Council seat say former Democratic Party boss Frank Seddio is playing politics by challenging their petitions to appear on the ballot. Seddio defended the petition challenges in the District 46 race, saying he is acting in the interests of the candidates his club endorses.

“We proudly filed them, and we’ll be filing more on Monday,” said Frank Seddio, president of the Thomas Jefferson Democratic Club, which filed the petition challenges. “We treat politics like war. We do everything we can to get our candidate elected.”

The 10-candidate race for District 46, which encompasses Canarsie, has drawn several Haitian-American contenders, including Mercedes Narcisse, Shirley Paul and Gardy Brazela.

Council candidates needed 270 signatures from fellow party members in their district by March 25 to get on the ballot for the June 22 primary election, according to state law. Registered voters in the district have through March 29 to object to signatures on any candidate’s designating petition.

Late evening on March 25, Narcisse’s lawyer informed her of an objection to her petition from the Thomas Jefferson Democratic Club, she said. Objections have also been filed against Paul, Dimple Wallabus and Donald Cranston, all of them Democrats. 

“That’s the game they play so they can hold power,” Narcisse said. “Now we’re going to organize, because all the other candidates called me [and] we’re putting ourselves together to say no.” 

Based in Canarsie and founded in 1955, the Thomas Jefferson club is considered by Brooklyn media to be one of the oldest and most powerful political clubs in the city. 

In the race to replace term-limited District 46 Council Member Alan Maisel, the club has endorsed two candidates in the race: Judy Newton and Brazela. As part of routine procedure, the club plans to challenge the eight candidates it has not endorsed, Seddio said.

Filing a general objection gives the filer six calendar days to submit a specific complaint or a claim that a candidate broke a specific rule in obtaining signatures. Hearings on petitions to determine if a candidate should remain on the ballot are scheduled to start April 13.

With COVID-19 still a major health crisis, the candidates affected are speaking out against the petition challenge. While challenges are a common practice, the candidates say they are uncalled for amid the COVID-19 pandemic, which made it harder to gather signatures in-person. Three candidates, including Narcisse, Paul, and Dimple Wallabus, planned to hold a press conference March 29, in front of the Thomas Jefferson club’s headquarters. 

Further, numerous politicians in citywide races have pledged not to challenge collected signatures, as a way to prioritize the public’s health.

Seddio, who stepped down as Democratic Party chair and was replaced by Rodneyse Bichotte-Hermelyn, said the District 46 candidates should expect such challenges. 

“This is a business,’” said Seddio, who is also a Democratic Party District Leader in Assembly District 59, which includes Canarsie. “If you want to [run against] the big guys, then play the big guys’ game.”

Candidates criticize political games during pandemic

To obtain signatures, candidates and their campaign volunteers typically go door-to-door or approach district residents in public spaces. 

State lawmakers this year reduced the number of signatures candidates need to obtain, due to the pandemic. Candidates citywide have unsuccessfully pressured lawmakers to remove the requirement for collecting signatures altogether. In February, more than 100 city candidates also filed a lawsuit, claiming the petition requirements during COVID-19 were unconstitutional. 

Citywide, some candidates for council, borough president and other races have pledged not to challenge each other’s signatures due to the pandemic. 

Despite the pledges, objections had been filed against 105 candidates across multiple citywide races as of 3:30 p.m. March 26, the city’s Board of Elections office confirmed in an email.

“During COVID it was already tough for us to get [signatures], and we were exercising caution,” said Paul 

Paul is confident her signatures are valid, she said. She and Narcisse both said they face the prospect of spending money on legal fees and taking time away from the campaign trail, due to the petition challenge. 

While she conceded that objecting to signatures is standard practice, Paul said the press conference will be a show of solidarity with other council candidates citywide, who agreed not to challenge each other. 

“We find it to be inappropriate to challenge at this time,” Paul said. “We’re going to do it to stand in unison with the other candidates throughout the city that are making people’s health number one.” 

Sam Bojarski can be reached at

Sam is a reporter for The Haitian Times and a 2020 Report for America corps member. He has covered Haiti and its diaspora since 2018. His work has also appeared in USA Today, the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review and Haiti Liberte. Sam can be reached at or on Twitter @sambojarski.

Join the Conversation

1 Comment

  1. Wow. Just wow. Seddio continues to be a massive, massive scumbag! People of good conscience need to continue organizing to get machine slime like this out of the Democratic party! We need to put this Tammany Hall trash out on a curb that’s far enough away that it can’t slither its way back into the house.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *